CHAPTER 11 ARENES AND AROMATICITY hapter and the next we extend our coverage of conjugated systems to include S. Arenes are hydrocarbons based on the benzene ring as a structural unit. Ben toluene, and naphthalene, for example, are arenes H HH HH HH Naphthalene One factor that makes conjugation in arenes special is its cyclic nature. A conju gated system that closes upon itself can have properties that are much different from those of open-chain polyenes. Arenes are also referred to as aromatic hydrocarbons Used in this sense, the word"aromatic"has nothing to do with odor but means instead that arenes are much more stable than we expect them to be based on their formulation as conjugated trienes. Our goal in this chapter is to det velo an ation for the cept of aromaticity-to see what are the properties of benzene and its derivatives that reflect its special stability, plore the reasons for it. This chapter develops the idea of the benzene ring as a fundamental structural unit and examines the effect of a benzene ring as a substituent. The chapter following this one describes reactions that rolve the ring its 398 Back Forward Main MenuToc Study Guide ToC Student o MHHE Website
398 CHAPTER 11 ARENES AND AROMATICITY I n this chapter and the next we extend our coverage of conjugated systems to include arenes. Arenes are hydrocarbons based on the benzene ring as a structural unit. Benzene, toluene, and naphthalene, for example, are arenes. One factor that makes conjugation in arenes special is its cyclic nature. A conjugated system that closes upon itself can have properties that are much different from those of open-chain polyenes. Arenes are also referred to as aromatic hydrocarbons. Used in this sense, the word “aromatic” has nothing to do with odor but means instead that arenes are much more stable than we expect them to be based on their formulation as conjugated trienes. Our goal in this chapter is to develop an appreciation for the concept of aromaticity—to see what are the properties of benzene and its derivatives that reflect its special stability, and to explore the reasons for it. This chapter develops the idea of the benzene ring as a fundamental structural unit and examines the effect of a benzene ring as a substituent. The chapter following this one describes reactions that involve the ring itself. H H H H H H Benzene H H H H H CH3 Toluene H H H H H H H H Naphthalene Back Forward Main Menu TOC Study Guide TOC Student OLC MHHE Website
11.1 Benzene Lets begin by tracing the history of benzene, its origin, and its structure. Many of the terms we use, including aromaticity itself, are of historical origin. We'll begin with the discovery of benzene 11.1 BENZENE In 1825, Michael Faraday isolated a new hydrocarbon from illuminating gas, which he Faraday is better know called"bicarburet of hydrogen. "Nine years later Eilhardt Mitscherlich of the University chemistry for his lawsor 3 of Berlin prepared the same substance by heating benzoic acid with lime and found to be a hydrocarbon having the empirical formula CnHn proposing the relationship C6HsCO,H Cao →C6H6+ strating the principle of Benzoic acid Calcium oxide Eventually, because of its relationship to benzoic acid, this hydrocarbon came to be named benzin, then later benzene, the name by which it is known today Benzoic acid had been known for several hundred years by the time of Mitscher- lich,s experiment. Many trees exude resinous materials called balsams when cuts are made in their bark. Some of these balsams are very fragrant, which once made them ghly prized articles of commerce, especially when the trees that produced them coul be found only in exotic, faraway lands. Gum benzoin is a balsam obtained from a tree that grows in Java and Sumatra. "Benzoin"is a word derived from the French equiva- lent, enjoin, which in turn comes from the Arabic luban jawi, meaning"incense from Java. "Benzoic acid is itself odorless but can easily be isolated from gum benzoin Compounds related to benzene were obtained from similar plant extracts. For example, a pleasant-smelling resin known as tolu balsam was obtained from the South American tolu tree. In the 1840s it was discovered that distillation of tolu balsam gave a methyl derivative of benzene, which, not surprisingly, came to be named toluene Although benzene and toluene are not particularly fragrant compounds themselves, their origins in aromatic plant extracts led them and compounds related to them to be classified as aromatic hydrocarbon.s. Alkanes, alkenes, and alkynes belong to another class, the aliphatic hydrocarbons. The word"aliphatic"comes from the greek aleiphar (meaning"oil"or"unguent)and was given to hydrocarbons that were obtained by the chemical degradation of fats Benzene was prepared from coal tar by August w. von Hofmann in 1845. Coal tar remained the primary source for the industrial production of benzene for many years, until petroleum-based technologies became competitive about 1950. Current production is about 6 million tons per year in the United States. A substantial portion of this ben zene is converted to styrene for use in the preparation of polystyrene plastics and films Toluene is also an important organic chemical. Like benzene, its early industrial production was from coal tar, but most of it now comes from petroleum 11.2 KEKULE AND THE STRUCTURE OF BENZENE The classification of hydrocarbons as aliphatic or aromatic took place in the 1860s when it was already apparent that there was something special about benzene, toluene, and their derivatives. Their molecular formulas(benzene is CH6 toluene is C7H) indicate that, like alkenes and alkynes, they are unsaturated and should undergo addition reac- tions. Under conditions in which bromine, for example, reacts rapidly with alkenes and Back Forward Main MenuToc Study Guide ToC Student o MHHE Website
Let’s begin by tracing the history of benzene, its origin, and its structure. Many of the terms we use, including aromaticity itself, are of historical origin. We’ll begin with the discovery of benzene. 11.1 BENZENE In 1825, Michael Faraday isolated a new hydrocarbon from illuminating gas, which he called “bicarburet of hydrogen.” Nine years later Eilhardt Mitscherlich of the University of Berlin prepared the same substance by heating benzoic acid with lime and found it to be a hydrocarbon having the empirical formula CnHn. Eventually, because of its relationship to benzoic acid, this hydrocarbon came to be named benzin, then later benzene, the name by which it is known today. Benzoic acid had been known for several hundred years by the time of Mitscherlich’s experiment. Many trees exude resinous materials called balsams when cuts are made in their bark. Some of these balsams are very fragrant, which once made them highly prized articles of commerce, especially when the trees that produced them could be found only in exotic, faraway lands. Gum benzoin is a balsam obtained from a tree that grows in Java and Sumatra. “Benzoin” is a word derived from the French equivalent, benjoin, which in turn comes from the Arabic luban jawi, meaning “incense from Java.” Benzoic acid is itself odorless but can easily be isolated from gum benzoin. Compounds related to benzene were obtained from similar plant extracts. For example, a pleasant-smelling resin known as tolu balsam was obtained from the South American tolu tree. In the 1840s it was discovered that distillation of tolu balsam gave a methyl derivative of benzene, which, not surprisingly, came to be named toluene. Although benzene and toluene are not particularly fragrant compounds themselves, their origins in aromatic plant extracts led them and compounds related to them to be classified as aromatic hydrocarbons. Alkanes, alkenes, and alkynes belong to another class, the aliphatic hydrocarbons. The word “aliphatic” comes from the Greek aleiphar (meaning “oil” or “unguent”) and was given to hydrocarbons that were obtained by the chemical degradation of fats. Benzene was prepared from coal tar by August W. von Hofmann in 1845. Coal tar remained the primary source for the industrial production of benzene for many years, until petroleum-based technologies became competitive about 1950. Current production is about 6 million tons per year in the United States. A substantial portion of this benzene is converted to styrene for use in the preparation of polystyrene plastics and films. Toluene is also an important organic chemical. Like benzene, its early industrial production was from coal tar, but most of it now comes from petroleum. 11.2 KEKULÉ AND THE STRUCTURE OF BENZENE The classification of hydrocarbons as aliphatic or aromatic took place in the 1860s when it was already apparent that there was something special about benzene, toluene, and their derivatives. Their molecular formulas (benzene is C6H6, toluene is C7H8) indicate that, like alkenes and alkynes, they are unsaturated and should undergo addition reactions. Under conditions in which bromine, for example, reacts rapidly with alkenes and C6H5CO2H Benzoic acid C6H6 Benzene CaO Calcium oxide CaCO3 Calcium carbonate heat 11.1 Benzene 399 Faraday is better known in chemistry for his laws of electrolysis and in physics for proposing the relationship between electric and magnetic fields and for demonstrating the principle of electromagnetic induction. Back Forward Main Menu TOC Study Guide TOC Student OLC MHHE Website
CHAPTER ELEVEN Arenes and Aromaticity alkynes, however, benzene proved to be inert. Benzene does react with Br2 in the pres ence of iron(im) bromide as a catalyst, but even then addition isnt observed Substitu- tion occurs instead no observable reaction Bromobenzene Hydrogen bromide Furthermore, only one monobromination product of benzene was ever obtained, which suggests that all the hydrogen atoms of benzene are equivalent. Substitution of one hydrogen by bromine gives the same product as substitution of any of the other hydrogens Chemists came to regard the six carbon atoms of benzene as a fundamental struc tural unit. Reactions could be carried out that altered its substituents, but the integrity of he benzene unit remained undisturbed. There must be something"special"about ben- zene that makes it inert to many of the reagents that add to alkenes and alkynes In 1866, only a few years after publishing his ideas concerning what we now rec- ognize as the structural theory of organic chemistry, August Kekule applied it to the structure of benzene. He based his reasoning on three premises 1. Benzene is Cah 2. All the hydrogens of benzene are equivalent. 3. The structural theory requires that there be four bonds to each carbon Kekule advanced the venturesome notion that the six carbon atoms of benzene were oschmidt, who was later to joined together in a ring. Four bonds to each carbon could be accommodated by a sys tem of alternating single and double bonds with one hydrogen on each carbon University of Vienna, pri- ining a structural formula for benzene similar to that H five years later. Loschmidt's ook reached few readers d his ideas were not well known H an you write? An article in a flaw in Kekule s structure for benzene was soon discovered. Kekule's structure the March 1994 issue of the quires that 1, 2-and 1, 6-disubstitution patterns create different compounds (isomers) Journal of Chemical Educa- ion(pp 222-224)claims ed and draws structural formulas for 25 of them 1. 2-Disubstituted 1.6-Disubstituted derivative of benzene derivative of benzene The two substituted carbons are connected by a double bond in one but by a single bond in the other. Since no such cases of isomerism in benzene derivatives were known and Back Forward Main MenuToc Study Guide ToC Student o MHHE Website
alkynes, however, benzene proved to be inert. Benzene does react with Br2 in the presence of iron(III) bromide as a catalyst, but even then addition isn’t observed. Substitution occurs instead! Furthermore, only one monobromination product of benzene was ever obtained, which suggests that all the hydrogen atoms of benzene are equivalent. Substitution of one hydrogen by bromine gives the same product as substitution of any of the other hydrogens. Chemists came to regard the six carbon atoms of benzene as a fundamental structural unit. Reactions could be carried out that altered its substituents, but the integrity of the benzene unit remained undisturbed. There must be something “special” about benzene that makes it inert to many of the reagents that add to alkenes and alkynes. In 1866, only a few years after publishing his ideas concerning what we now recognize as the structural theory of organic chemistry, August Kekulé applied it to the structure of benzene. He based his reasoning on three premises: 1. Benzene is C6H6. 2. All the hydrogens of benzene are equivalent. 3. The structural theory requires that there be four bonds to each carbon. Kekulé advanced the venturesome notion that the six carbon atoms of benzene were joined together in a ring. Four bonds to each carbon could be accommodated by a system of alternating single and double bonds with one hydrogen on each carbon. A flaw in Kekulé’s structure for benzene was soon discovered. Kekulé’s structure requires that 1,2- and 1,6-disubstitution patterns create different compounds (isomers). The two substituted carbons are connected by a double bond in one but by a single bond in the other. Since no such cases of isomerism in benzene derivatives were known, and X X 1 4 2 3 6 5 1,2-Disubstituted derivative of benzene X X 1 4 2 3 6 5 1,6-Disubstituted derivative of benzene C C H C C H C C H H 1 2 3 4 6 5 H H C6H6 Benzene Br2 Bromine CCl4 FeBr3 no observable reaction C6H5Br Bromobenzene HBr Hydrogen bromide 400 CHAPTER ELEVEN Arenes and Aromaticity In 1861, Johann Josef Loschmidt, who was later to become a professor at the University of Vienna, privately published a book containing a structural formula for benzene similar to that which Kekulé would propose five years later. Loschmidt’s book reached few readers, and his ideas were not well known. How many isomers of C6H6 can you write? An article in the March 1994 issue of the Journal of Chemical Education (pp. 222–224) claims that there are several hundred and draws structural formulas for 25 of them. Back Forward Main Menu TOC Study Guide TOC Student OLC MHHE Website
11.2 Kekule and the structure of benzene BENZENE DREAMS AND CREATIVE THINKING t ceremonies in Berlin in 1890 celebrating the Let us learn to dream, then perhaps we shall twenty-fifth anniversary of his proposed struc- find the truth. But let us beware of publishing ture of benzene, August Kekule recalled the our dreams before they have been put to th thinking that led him to it. He began by noting that proof by the waking understanding the idea of the structural theory came to him during The imagery of a whirling circle of snakes evokes a a daydream while on a bus in London. Kekule went vivid picture that engages one's attention when first on to describe the origins of his view of the benzene exposed to Kekule's model of the benzene structure. structure Recently, however, the opinion has been expressed There I sat and wrote for my textbook; but that Kekule might have engaged in some hyperbole with other matters. I turned the chair towards Illinois University suggests that discoveries in science atoms danced before my eyes. This time smaller body of experimental observations to progress to a groups modestly remained in the background. higher level of understanding. Wotiz'view that My mental eye, sharpened by repeated appari- Kekule's account is more fanciful than accurate has joined more densely; everything in motion, yond the history of organic chemistry. How does cre- what was that? One of the snakes caught hold more creative? Because these are questions that have of its own tail and mockingly whirled round be. concerned psychologists for decades, the idea of a fore my eyes. I awoke as if by lightning: this sleepy Kekule being more creative than an alert time, too, I spent the rest of the night working Kekule becomes more than simply a charming story out the consequences of this hypothesis he once told about himself Concluding his remarks, Kekule merged his advocacy of creative imagination with the rigorous standards Hafner published in Angew. Chem. Internat. edEngl! of science by reminding his audience 641-651(1979) none could be found, Kekule suggested that two isomeric structures could exist but inter converted too rapidly to be separated X Kekule's ideas about the structure of benzene left an important question unan- swered. What is it about benzene that makes it behave so much differently from other unsaturated compounds? We'll see in this chapter that the answer is a simple one-the low reactivity of benzene and its derivatives reflects their special stability. Kekule was Benzene is lohexatriene. nor is it air of rapidly equilibrating cyclo hexatriene isomers. But there was no way that Kekule could have gotten it right given the state of chemical know ledge at the time. After all, the electron hadnt even been dis- onding to provi insight into why benzene is so stable. We'll outline these theories shortly. First, how ever. let's look at the structure of benzene in more detail Back Forward Main MenuToc Study Guide ToC Student o MHHE Website
none could be found, Kekulé suggested that two isomeric structures could exist but interconverted too rapidly to be separated. Kekulé’s ideas about the structure of benzene left an important question unanswered. What is it about benzene that makes it behave so much differently from other unsaturated compounds? We’ll see in this chapter that the answer is a simple one—the low reactivity of benzene and its derivatives reflects their special stability. Kekulé was wrong. Benzene is not cyclohexatriene, nor is it a pair of rapidly equilibrating cyclohexatriene isomers. But there was no way that Kekulé could have gotten it right given the state of chemical knowledge at the time. After all, the electron hadn’t even been discovered yet. It remained for twentieth-century electronic theories of bonding to provide insight into why benzene is so stable. We’ll outline these theories shortly. First, however, let’s look at the structure of benzene in more detail. X X X X fast 11.2 Kekulé and the Structure of Benzene 401 BENZENE, DREAMS, AND CREATIVE THINKING At ceremonies in Berlin in 1890 celebrating the twenty-fifth anniversary of his proposed structure of benzene, August Kekulé recalled the thinking that led him to it. He began by noting that the idea of the structural theory came to him during a daydream while on a bus in London. Kekulé went on to describe the origins of his view of the benzene structure. There I sat and wrote for my textbook; but things did not go well; my mind was occupied with other matters. I turned the chair towards the fireplace and began to doze. Once again the atoms danced before my eyes. This time smaller groups modestly remained in the background. My mental eye, sharpened by repeated apparitions of similar kind, now distinguished larger units of various shapes. Long rows, frequently joined more densely; everything in motion, twisting and turning like snakes. And behold, what was that? One of the snakes caught hold of its own tail and mockingly whirled round before my eyes. I awoke, as if by lightning; this time, too, I spent the rest of the night working out the consequences of this hypothesis.* Concluding his remarks, Kekulé merged his advocacy of creative imagination with the rigorous standards of science by reminding his audience: Let us learn to dream, then perhaps we shall find the truth. But let us beware of publishing our dreams before they have been put to the proof by the waking understanding. The imagery of a whirling circle of snakes evokes a vivid picture that engages one’s attention when first exposed to Kekulé’s model of the benzene structure. Recently, however, the opinion has been expressed that Kekulé might have engaged in some hyperbole during his speech. Professor John Wotiz of Southern Illinois University suggests that discoveries in science are the result of a disciplined analysis of a sufficient body of experimental observations to progress to a higher level of understanding. Wotiz’ view that Kekulé’s account is more fanciful than accurate has sparked a controversy with ramifications that go beyond the history of organic chemistry. How does creative thought originate? What can we do to become more creative? Because these are questions that have concerned psychologists for decades, the idea of a sleepy Kekulé being more creative than an alert Kekulé becomes more than simply a charming story he once told about himself. * The Kekulé quotes are taken from the biographical article of K. Hafner published in Angew. Chem. Internat. ed. Engl. 18, 641–651 (1979). Back Forward Main Menu TOC Study Guide TOC Student OLC MHHE Website
CHAPTER ELEVEN Arenes and Aromaticity Benzene is planar and its carbon skeleton has the shape of a regular hexagon. There is no evidence that it has alternating single and double bonds. As shown in Figure 11.1 all the carbon-carbon bonds are the same length(140 pm) and the 120 bond angles cor respond to perfect sp- hybridization. Interestingly, the 140-pm bond distances in benzene are exactly midway between the typical sp--sp" single-bond distance of 146 pm and the sp-sp- double-bond distance of 134 pm. If bond distances are related to bond type, what kind of carbon-carbon bond is it that lies halfway between a single bond and a double bond in length? 11.3 A RESONANCE PICTURE OF BONDING IN BENZENE Twentieth- -century theories of bonding in benzene provide a rather clear picture of aro- maticity. We'll start with a resonance description of benzene The two Kekule structures for benzene have the same arrangement of atoms but differ in the placement of electrons. Thus they are resonance forms, and neither one by itself correctly describes the bonding in the actual molecule. As a hybrid of the two Kekule structures, benzene is often represented by a hexagon containing an inscribed The circle-in-a-hexagon symbol was first suggested by the British chemist Sir Robert Robinson to represent what he called the"aromatic sextet'-the six delocalized T electrons of the three double bonds. Robinsons symbol is a convenient time-saving shorthand device, but Kekule-type formulas are better for counting and keeping track of electrons, especially in chemical reactions PROBLEM 11.1 Write structural formulas for toluene(cshs cha) and for benzoic acid (C,Hs Co2 H)(a)as resonance hybrids of two Kekule forms and( b)with the 140pm 108pm FIGURE 11.1 Bond distances and bond angles of benzen Back Forward Main MenuToc Study Guide ToC Student o MHHE Website
Benzene is planar and its carbon skeleton has the shape of a regular hexagon. There is no evidence that it has alternating single and double bonds. As shown in Figure 11.1, all the carbon–carbon bonds are the same length (140 pm) and the 120° bond angles correspond to perfect sp2 hybridization. Interestingly, the 140-pm bond distances in benzene are exactly midway between the typical sp2 –sp2 single-bond distance of 146 pm and the sp2 –sp2 double-bond distance of 134 pm. If bond distances are related to bond type, what kind of carbon–carbon bond is it that lies halfway between a single bond and a double bond in length? 11.3 A RESONANCE PICTURE OF BONDING IN BENZENE Twentieth-century theories of bonding in benzene provide a rather clear picture of aromaticity. We’ll start with a resonance description of benzene. The two Kekulé structures for benzene have the same arrangement of atoms, but differ in the placement of electrons. Thus they are resonance forms, and neither one by itself correctly describes the bonding in the actual molecule. As a hybrid of the two Kekulé structures, benzene is often represented by a hexagon containing an inscribed circle. The circle-in-a-hexagon symbol was first suggested by the British chemist Sir Robert Robinson to represent what he called the “aromatic sextet”—the six delocalized electrons of the three double bonds. Robinson’s symbol is a convenient time-saving shorthand device, but Kekulé-type formulas are better for counting and keeping track of electrons, especially in chemical reactions. PROBLEM 11.1 Write structural formulas for toluene (C6H5CH3) and for benzoic acid (C6H5CO2H) (a) as resonance hybrids of two Kekulé forms and (b) with the Robinson symbol. is equivalent to 402 CHAPTER ELEVEN Arenes and Aromaticity 120 120 120 140 pm 108 pm FIGURE 11.1 Bond distances and bond angles of benzene. Back Forward Main Menu TOC Study Guide TOC Student OLC MHHE Website